The Ivy League Just Got Ranked Below State Schools in Texas and Florida — and the Methodology Is Brutal

The Ivy League Just Got Ranked Below State Schools in Texas and Florida — and the Methodology Is Brutal

Brown University — annual tuition somewhere north of $67,000 — just ranked 73rd out of 115 schools in a new set of college rankings. The University of Florida ranked first. The University of Texas at Austin ranked second.

The eight Ivy League schools averaged a rank of 42nd. The two flagship publics that beat all of them charge a fraction of the price.

The Manhattan Institute released its 2026 City Journal College Rankings on November 10, evaluating 115 of America's most prominent universities across 95 variables on a 100-point scale. The four scoring categories — Governance Quality worth 20 points, Educational Experience worth 30, Student Life worth 10, and Outcomes worth a dominant 40 — were designed to measure what schools actually deliver, not how many applicants they reject.

Kevin Wallsten, a professor of political science at California State University, Long Beach and a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, described the project as offering students and families "an empirically grounded tool for deciding which schools are deserving of their time, their money — and their trust."

The results are something. Not a single school out of 115 scored above 80. Only seven earned a 70 or higher. Eighty-seven schools — 94 percent of those evaluated — scored below 60. The average score across American higher education landed at 50 out of 100.

The Ivy League breakdown tells the real story. Penn came in at 17. Princeton at 24. Yale at 30. Columbia at 34. Harvard — the name that's supposed to end all arguments — landed at 37. Dartmouth fell to 57. Cornell to 61. Brown brought up the rear at 73. Average Ivy tuition: $67,600 per year.

The University of Notre Dame rounded out the top three behind UT Austin and Florida. Claremont McKenna College cracked the top five.

What makes the 2026 edition particularly pointed is what the Manhattan Institute added to the methodology. Researchers analyzed nearly 3,000 faculty biographies and coded over 24,000 course descriptions for Western canon versus progressive vocabulary. They tracked campaign contributions to measure political diversity among faculty and staff using federal election records. They assessed foreign funding — specifically gifts and contracts from China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea. They tracked which schools actually eliminated DEI offices versus which ones just rebranded them.

Even the top performers showed cracks. The University of North Carolina ranked 6th overall but came in 88th on faculty ideological pluralism. UT Austin — the number-one school in America by this measure — ranked 106th on student self-censorship. Notre Dame placed 110th on administrative support for free expression.

The broader context is hard to ignore. A 2025 Pew survey found 70 percent of Americans believe higher education is heading in the "wrong direction." Gallup tracked confidence in higher education dropping from 57 percent to 38 percent. Only 31 percent of Americans now say a college education is "very important" — the lowest since Gallup started asking in 1978.

Former Barnard College President Judith Shapiro once said the job of higher education is to develop an inner life rich enough that "the inside of your head is an interesting place to spend the rest of your life." At $67,600 a year, the Ivy League is charging luxury-car prices for that inner life while public schools in Texas and Florida are delivering better results on 95 measurable variables.

Harvard ranked 37th. Brown ranked 73rd. The full rankings are live at collegerankings.city-journal.org.


Most Popular

Most Popular